TesT
[M:-92117]
Posts: 49,581
|
Post by TesT on Dec 9, 2007 20:41:08 GMT -5
Styles played CB3 at the beginning of the season. Doesnt that mean he no longer qualifies as a redshirt?
|
|
TesT
[M:-92117]
Posts: 49,581
|
Post by TesT on Dec 9, 2007 20:42:30 GMT -5
|
|
MiniHusk
Roseville Bunnies[M:-6550]
Yetis4Lyfe
Posts: 5,811
|
Post by MiniHusk on Dec 9, 2007 20:45:41 GMT -5
Styles played CB3 at the beginning of the season. Doesnt that mean he no longer qualifies as a redshirt? nope, he hasn't gained any performance points there, also: Yes. It's not a part of the rule, but we wanted to pass along a suggestion that you guys waive the position limitation for the first three weeks of the season. For example... let's say the Cougars have a rookie at MLB2 and have been playing a 3-4 base defense. So long as they don't play a 3-4 anymore, or if they move him to another eligible position, that player could be eligible for redshirt. Or they could leave him where he is, and he would still be eligible until he manages to pick up some attribute points.
|
|
TesT
[M:-92117]
Posts: 49,581
|
Post by TesT on Dec 9, 2007 20:46:45 GMT -5
Ok, just checking.
|
|
MiniHusk
Roseville Bunnies[M:-6550]
Yetis4Lyfe
Posts: 5,811
|
Post by MiniHusk on Dec 9, 2007 20:47:26 GMT -5
Ok, just checking. i thoroughly read those rules
|
|
TesT
[M:-92117]
Posts: 49,581
|
Post by TesT on Dec 9, 2007 20:48:59 GMT -5
You know the 46 includes some 3-4 packages...I believe. So if you guys do use that, you run the risk of him earning PPS.
|
|
MiniHusk
Roseville Bunnies[M:-6550]
Yetis4Lyfe
Posts: 5,811
|
Post by MiniHusk on Dec 9, 2007 20:55:58 GMT -5
You know the 46 includes some 3-4 packages...I believe. So if you guys do use that, you run the risk of him earning PPS. the 46 was not mentioned in the official rules regarding 3-4 formations 4) A player occupying the MLB2 position will not gain eligibility for redshirt due to his roster position if his team utilizes a 3-4 base defense, as this effectively makes him a starter (3-4, BAL, CLE, DAL, MIA, NE, NYJ, PIT, SD, SF). The player may still qualify for redshirt if he does not earn any performance points per section 2. He is a MLB2, so he is eligible for a redshirt, even if he does gain performance points, just as long as we don't use one of the mentioned Defensive PBs
|
|
TesT
[M:-92117]
Posts: 49,581
|
Post by TesT on Dec 9, 2007 21:59:37 GMT -5
Part 4 says to me...if you have him placed at MLB2 then you can't use any of those defensive packages. Ok...fine. You're using the 46. But..it says the reference section 2. Which says a player cannot gain any PPs prior to W10.
My understanding is that if you use say a 4-3 D and he gains PPS, then he still loses his redshirt.
|
|
Tommygamer
[M:-1030]
_Tomko Brewski_ _Polish Power_
Posts: 5,413
|
Post by Tommygamer on Dec 9, 2007 22:26:34 GMT -5
Part 4 says to me...if you have him placed at MLB2 then you can't use any of those defensive packages. Ok...fine. You're using the 46. But..it says the reference section 2. Which says a player cannot gain any PPs prior to W10. My understanding is that if you use say a 4-3 D and he gains PPS, then he still loses his redshirt. Redshirt eligibilty if: 1 - no performance points earned - even if in one of those starting positions, or 2 - never play in one of those starting positions - and even if performance points are earned, then it is OK. As the 4-6 was not included in the rules, a player at MLB2 will not be considered a starting player.
|
|
captobvious
Hall of Famer[/i]
[M:8550]
Liam McNasty - MLB
Posts: 6,288
|
Post by captobvious on Dec 9, 2007 22:31:38 GMT -5
If the 46 uses the 3-4, then it needs to be added. We didn't have any info on the generic playbooks when we put that together... just the ones with team names. If there are any others, they should be added as well.
And, as my quote says, it is a recommendation. It is up to the commish and GM office to decide on that. We write the rules... individual judgements on exceptions is not our realm.
|
|
|
Post by I Make Plays..... 14 on Dec 9, 2007 22:50:01 GMT -5
If the 46 uses the 3-4, then it needs to be added. We didn't have any info on the generic playbooks when we put that together... just the ones with team names. If there are any others, they should be added as well. And, as my quote says, it is a recommendation. It is up to the commish and GM office to decide on that. We write the rules... individual judgements on exceptions is not our realm. In a 46 defense, the base is 3 linebackers. There is 2 formations which include a 3-4 also.. Can't we just run it, and not allow them any performance points? It's overkill on the restrictions...
|
|
MiniHusk
Roseville Bunnies[M:-6550]
Yetis4Lyfe
Posts: 5,811
|
Post by MiniHusk on Dec 10, 2007 1:52:25 GMT -5
Part 4 says to me...if you have him placed at MLB2 then you can't use any of those defensive packages. Ok...fine. You're using the 46. But..it says the reference section 2. Which says a player cannot gain any PPs prior to W10. My understanding is that if you use say a 4-3 D and he gains PPS, then he still loses his redshirt. No, thats not true. If he plays MLB2, he can gain all of the performance points he wants as long as he does not play in a 3-4 based Defense. The 46 is a 3 LB base:
|
|
MiniHusk
Roseville Bunnies[M:-6550]
Yetis4Lyfe
Posts: 5,811
|
Post by MiniHusk on Dec 10, 2007 2:48:11 GMT -5
If we limit the 46 from being used, then we must limit the Cover 2 from being used because the Cover 2 has 1 3-4 package and the 46 has 2 3-4 packages
|
|
MiniHusk
Roseville Bunnies[M:-6550]
Yetis4Lyfe
Posts: 5,811
|
Post by MiniHusk on Jan 10, 2008 12:16:55 GMT -5
updated for W10
|
|
|
Post by I Make Plays..... 14 on Jan 10, 2008 17:43:19 GMT -5
Vince Hall from FB1 to FB2/TE3 Zach Dorow from FB2/TE3 to FB1
Chris Jones to WR3, Matty Smith to WR4
|
|